Home »
Since 1917, Nottingham Insurance has been a staple of our local and national communities. We are family-owned and cared for.
We have thrived for over 100 years.
Since our founding, we have lived through pivotal changes in our industry. After surviving the Great Depression, our founder Major’s son, Stanley Nutt, joined the agency. His dynamic energy and unwavering dedication to his new profession propelled the agency’s evolution, leading to its transformation into the Stanley Nutt Agency several years later.
100
Years in Business
40
States Served
We have generations of insurance experience.
The year 1965 marked the beginning of another new generation, as Jack Blair Sr., Stanley’s son-in-law, quit his job at Ford Motor company to join the family business. Under Jack’s guidance, the agency embraced change, prompting another rebranding, this time to Nottingham Insurance. This evolution captured the essence of legacy and the agency’s expanding horizons. Following in their father’s footsteps, Jack Blair Jr. and Greg Blair joined the agency in the 1980s as fourth-generation insurance agents.
We have our eyes on the future.
Several strategic acquisitions helped us grow both our staff and book of business, further cementing our position as the agency of choice for the tri-state area. Today, Nottingham Insurance stands as a testament to the resilience, adaptability, and enduring values that our original founder, Major Voorhees Nutt, instilled over a century ago. Through four generations of visionary leadership, strategic partnerships, and a commitment to clients, the agency’s journey remains a beacon of excellence, integrity, and unwavering dedication.
250
Five-Star Reviews
The Independent Agency Advantage
Here’s what makes our insurance agency different.
Volunteer Organizations
- Hamilton YMCA
- Project Freedom
- Mobile Meals of Hamilton
- Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital – Hamilton
- Shop Hamilton
- Rotary Club of Robbinsville Hamilton
- Rotary Club of Willow Grove
- Megan’s Place
- Miracle League of Mercer County
Awards
- Business Insurance – Best Places to Work 2022
- Business Insurance – Best Places to Work 2023
- Princeton Mercer Regional Chamber of Commerce – Small Business of the Year (2022)
- Robert Wood Johnson Corporate Honoree (2011)
- Hamilton Education Foundation – Business Leader Award (2017)
- Hamilton Area YMCA – Community Achievement Award (2004)
- Township of Hamilton – Distinguished Achievement Award – Local Business Award (2001)
- Catholic Charities – Leadership Sponsor (2008)
Our Associations
Our Mission
Nottingham Insurance strives to be the trusted independent insurance agency of choice for businesses and families, empowering them to feel confident and secure in their insurance coverages through exceptional customer service while preserving our legacy as a family-owned organization for generations to come.
Contact UsMeet Our Team
Nottingham Insurance is located in Hamilton, NJ, and proudly serves over 40 states across the US
Let’s Get Started
Request an Insurance Quote
"*" indicates required fields
Don’t like forms? Contact us at 609-587-1600 or email us.
